Do you really need a manual breast pump?

As an auxiliary tool for breastfeeding mothers, a breast pump plays an important role in daily life. Not only does it help mothers manage breastfeeding time flexibly, but it also efficiently collects and stores breast milk. Compared to electric breast pumps, manual ones are more cost-effective.

In this article, we will explore the advantages and disadvantages of manual breast pumps and the different types of mothers they are suitable for. Whether you are a mother who occasionally needs to pump or one who pumps frequently, we will provide relevant advice and tips to help you choose the right breast pump for yourself and enhance your breastfeeding journey for a better experience and results. Let's delve into the mysteries of manual breast pumps together!

Mothers use wearable breast pumps at work

Types of Mothers Suitable for Using Manual Breast Pumps

Manual breast pumps are not suitable for all breastfeeding mothers, but they may be an ideal choice for certain types of mothers.

 Mothers who occasionally pump and do not rely on expressed breast milk as the baby's primary source of nutrition

In this case, manual breast pumps have the following advantages:

Cost-effectiveness: Manual breast pumps are usually cheaper than electric ones, suitable for mothers who do not pump frequently and do not depend on expressed breast milk as the baby's primary source of nutrition.
Portability: Manual breast pumps are compact and lightweight, easy to carry.

Mothers who have electric breast pumps but need a backup plan

For mothers who already have electric breast pumps, using a manual breast pump as a backup plan has the following advantages:

Dealing with electric pump failures: When an electric breast pump malfunctions or cannot be used, a manual breast pump can serve as an alternative to ensure the baby gets the necessary breast milk.
Effective milk emptying: Sometimes mothers experience breast engorgement, and the suction of an electric breast pump may not be strong enough, requiring a manual breast pump to empty the breast milk. Therefore, it can complement an electric breast pump, providing more options.

Drawbacks of Manual Pumps for Mothers who Pump Frequently

Although manual breast pumps are a good choice for certain types of mothers, they may have some drawbacks for mothers who pump frequently.


Manual operation: Manual breast pumps require hand movements to generate suction, which can lead to fatigue during prolonged use.
Pumping speed: Compared to electric breast pumps, manual ones generally have a slower pumping speed, requiring more time to complete the pumping process.
To address these issues, mothers can consider the following suggestions or techniques to reduce time consumption:

Scheduled pumping: Set fixed pumping times to avoid pumping too frequently or irregularly.
Comfortable posture: Choose an appropriate pumping posture to stay comfortable and relaxed, helping to reduce hand fatigue.

Wrist fatigue

Hand movements: Prolonged manual operation can cause hand muscle fatigue and discomfort.
Continuous pressure: To maintain suction, mothers may need to continuously apply some pressure, which can also increase hand fatigue.
To address wrist fatigue issues, mothers can consider the following methods or product recommendations for relief:

Use gloves or hand creams: Protect the skin on hands, reduce friction, and discomfort.
Consider purchasing a manual breast pump with ergonomic design: These products typically reduce hand fatigue and improve pumping efficiency.

These issues and solutions demonstrate the challenges manual breast pumps may pose for mothers who pump frequently and provide practical advice and tips to address these issues, ensuring a more comfortable and smooth breastfeeding process.

While manual breast pumps as an alternative have clear advantages in certain situations, they also have some drawbacks. When choosing a manual breast pump, it's essential to weigh and consider individual needs and circumstances.

For mothers who occasionally pump and do not rely on expressed breast milk as the baby's primary source of nutrition, a manual breast pump is a cost-effective and portable choice. Additionally, for mothers who already have electric breast pumps, a manual breast pump can serve as a backup plan to deal with electric pump failures or for specific occasions.

However, for mothers who pump frequently, manual breast pumps may have drawbacks such as time consumption and wrist fatigue. To address these issues, mothers can use techniques like scheduled pumping, adopting comfortable postures, and using manual breast pumps with ergonomic designs to alleviate discomfort and enhance efficiency.

In conclusion, whether choosing a manual or electric breast pump, the key is to make the selection based on individual needs and circumstances and adapt flexibly to different breastfeeding requirements. The ultimate goal is to ensure the baby receives sufficient breast milk and make the breastfeeding process more comfortable and smooth.

Continue reading